Skip to content
Healthcare Insider with YEM logo

Episode 6 · ~7:10

Dignity of Risk

Fictional. Includes mature themes.

An older woman in a diner booth with a slice of pie, with the words SHE’S 71. SHE WANTS A DATE.Coming soon

Listen instead

Audio coming soon for “Episode 6: Dignity of Risk”.

The question

Should Ms. Ruth go on that date alone? Can her niece stop her?

Comments

Join free to have your say.

Join free to have your say
Full transcript

NARRATOR: Episode five. Dignity of Risk. This episode is fictional and includes mature themes.

NARRATOR: 9:12 PM. A door alarm chirps. Amara pushes open Ms. Ruth’s bedroom door. The bed is made. The walker is gone. So is Ms. Ruth.

AMARA (into phone, breathless): Keisha, Ms. Ruth is gone. I’ve checked the whole house. She’s not here.

NARRATOR: A 71-year-old woman who falls when she rushes was somewhere out in the dark. And everybody in this house knew exactly why she’d left.

NARRATOR: Behind the Unit Door. Dignity of Risk.

NARRATOR: Three days earlier…

Wednesday: Walter

NARRATOR: The van, after day program. Ms. Ruth is grinning at her window like a teenager.

MS. RUTH: His name is Walter. He’s seventy-four. He wears a bow tie on Fridays. And he asked me to the diner on Fifth Street. Saturday. Just me and him.

AMARA (smiling): Ms. Ruth! Look at you!

MS. RUTH: Don’t you tell anybody. They’ll ruin it.

NARRATOR: She’d lived in group homes for forty years. She’d never once been on a date.

Thursday: The meeting

NARRATOR: Keisha’s office. Keisha, Daniel, Amara. Ms. Ruth’s niece, Denise, on speakerphone.

KEISHA: She’s a fall risk. She doesn’t do crosswalks well. If something happens on that walk, it’s on us. It’s on the agency.

DENISE (on speaker): Absolutely not. My aunt is not… she can’t be dating. Some old man from a day program? What does he want with her?

DANIEL (careful): Last year a resident from another house went out alone and was missing for six hours. I’m not saying no. I’m saying I’ve seen how this goes wrong.

AMARA: Ms. Ruth doesn’t have a guardian. She signs her own papers. She makes her own choices. We keep saying “person-centered.” Is it only person-centered when it’s convenient?

KEISHA: …Fine. She can go. With a staff member at the next table.

NARRATOR: Ms. Ruth’s face when she’s told.

MS. RUTH: A chaperone? I’m seventy-one years old!

Saturday, 9:12 PM: Missing

NARRATOR: Amara does exactly what the missing-person protocol says: searches every room, the yard, the garage. Calls Keisha. Calls the on-call. Writes the time down.

KEISHA (on phone): If you don’t find her in the next few minutes, you call 911. That’s the policy. Don’t wait.

NARRATOR: Amara stands in the driveway, thinking. Then her eyes widen.

AMARA: The diner. Fifth Street.

NARRATOR: She calls 911 to report Ms. Ruth missing, gives her description, and tells them where she might be. Daniel stays with the other residents while Amara drives.

9:31 PM: The diner

NARRATOR: Through the diner window: Ms. Ruth and Walter, in a corner booth, sharing a slice of peach pie. Walter is in a bow tie. Ms. Ruth is laughing so hard she’s crying.

NARRATOR: Amara walks in. Ms. Ruth sees her and straightens up, defiant.

MS. RUTH: Don’t you dare drag me out of here.

AMARA (sitting down, shaking): You scared me to death. I called the police, Ms. Ruth.

MS. RUTH: For fifty years, people have decided for me. When I eat. When I sleep. Who I see. I am not asking anybody’s permission to be happy for one hour.

NARRATOR: Amara calls 911 back to say Ms. Ruth is found and safe. Then she looks at Walter, who slides the pie toward her.

WALTER: Want a bite? It’s good pie.

NARRATOR: 10:15 PM. Back at the house. A car screeches into the driveway. Denise storms in.

DENISE: That’s it. I’m calling a lawyer in the morning. I’m filing for guardianship. She clearly can’t make her own decisions.

MS. RUTH (quiet, steady): You’d take away my rights… because I had pie with a man?

DENISE: Because you snuck out in the dark with a walker!

MS. RUTH: I snuck out because none of you would let me walk out the front door.

NARRATOR: Silence. Everyone looks at Amara. Keisha. Daniel. Nobody has an answer.

NARRATOR: She was safe. She was happy. And she might be about to lose the right to choose anything ever again.

A closing word from Yem

YEM: I’m Yem, your Healthcare Insider. This one is about the people we support, not us. So let’s put them first.

There’s an idea in our field called dignity of risk. It means people with disabilities have the right to take reasonable risks, just like everybody else: to date, to walk to the store, to make a choice we wouldn’t make. When we say no to everything “for safety,” we don’t just keep people safe. We take their life away from them.

So the question in a team meeting shouldn’t be “Can she?” It should be “How do we help her do it safely?” Practice the route together. Put a phone in her hand and teach her to use it. Agree on a check-in time. Meet Walter. That’s real person-centered planning.

And if someone doesn’t have a court-appointed guardian, in most places they make their own decisions, even ones their family hates. Guardianship is a big legal step that can take away a lot of rights. Many states now recognize less restrictive options, like supported decision-making. Families, your fear comes from love. But fear isn’t a reason to take someone’s voice.

And DSPs: watch what Amara did when Ms. Ruth was missing. She followed the protocol, wrote down the times and called 911 without waiting. Whatever you believe about the date, that part is not optional.

So tell me: Should Ms. Ruth have been allowed to go on that date alone? And should her niece be able to stop her? Comments are open. I want to hear from DSPs, families and managers on this one.

I’m Yem — your Healthcare Insider. I’ve been behind that unit door, and I’m not leaving you there alone. Share this with a DSP who needs it, and I’ll see you on the next shift.

Fictional story. Names and agencies are invented. Rules differ by state and employer. This is not legal or medical advice.